Do the Panthers Have What It Takes to Compete?
The free agency frenzy of July 1st, and the time following up to training camp in September; can be a very disconcerting time for fans of hockey in general Panthers faithful in particular. Seeing as Southern Florida with its unreliable fanbase and notably hot yet unhockey-like environment – is anything but a magnet when it comes to attracting hockey players of note – it is not surprising that the tune sung around this Floridian camp is usually a somber one; if not downright depressing this time of year. And that’s not to say that things usually get any better – at whatever time of – the following season either….
It’s sad to say, but this year does not seem to be a notable exception to this solemn hymn of Floridian hockey frenzy’d despair. Yes, the Florida Panthers have actually been very active this time around on the marketplace, but, despite some quality signings it is a bit of a stretch of the imagination to say that the club has necessarily got better. The squad may be cheaper, which will undoubtedly warm the hearts of current and prospective owners, but better…?
Last season the club did break out of early season mediocrity to make a bonafide all-out assault on the Eastern Conference Top 8. However, despite a string of impressive performances – all of which seemed to stem from the teams energetic new young coach Pete DeBoer; his strong goaltending tandem and sturdy defense. Especially the latter contributed considerably to any success the Cats found in mid-season last campaign. Not only were the top six warding off opponents, but also at times, they were the team’s main scoring threat – notching up many timely and important goals.
After the trade deadline however, the wheels came off of the Panthers’ post-season challenge. The defense in particular, was not as strong as previously, and the goalscoring woes of the forwards continued unabated. Not even the goaltenders could stem the flow now and Florida’s playoff charge quickly derailed – and this despite the struggles and continued woes of the centennial celebrators in Montreal. Tied on points, but with an inferior wins statistic, it was the Habs and not the Cats that progressed. A bitter end to what seemed like a very promising campaign, just a couple of months earlier.
The failure to upgrade at the transfer deadline cost the Panthers dearly. Other teams that provided the Cats’ major competition – the NY Rangers. Pittsburgh Penguins, Philadelphia Flyers, Carolina Hurricanes – all improved their squads at the deadline. Florida did not and the wheels subsequently soon fell off the wagon train down the bumpy stretch called “the playoff race”. Especially pending free agent Jay Bouwmeester looked lackluster toward the end and failed to justify just why the franchise had been so desperate to keep hold of him – despite mouthwatering deals proposed by other teams. The organization and GM Jacques Martin in particular, took a huge gamble in Jay-Bo and unfortunately it not only failed to pay off – but even seemed to backfire on the club – both short term and long term.
The latter consequence was losing the marquee player for a lowly 3rd Round Pick in the 2009 entry draft, whilst also securing the negotiating rights with Jordan Leopold prior to free agency. Leopold was eventually signed to a one year deal and his signing remains the one major addition to next year’s team. A flurry of other names have also come, and gone, but with the exception of local hero David Booth – and his spanking new 6 year contract; there is precious little to get excited about for Panthers fans.
To be fair to current interim boss Randy Sexton, he has probably done the very best he could have hoped to do – considering the limitations which have no doubt been placed upon his shoulders and which are out of his hands. Indeed, I have been most impressed with how he has handled himself and picked up the jumbled mess that Jacques Martin left behind him when he skipped ship a month ago. In my opinion Sexton has deserved the chance to be named General Manager on a more long term basis. But kid yourself not, this doesn’t mean that the franchise is finally set to turn a corner, rather, I would not be wholly surprised if the organization once again is forced into rebuilding mode.
Looking at our team and comparing it to fellow Southeastern Division rivals, it must be said that the Panthers look weaker this year; compared to last. This while all the other teams look like they’ve added significantly to last season’s squads. Not least our rivals across the state look like they finally have got their act together and could be set for a year of resurgence. Atlanta too – look like they might be able to compete, after a strong finish to last season and some quality additions to the formerly threadbare roster. The Carolina Hurricanes and Washington Capitals have meanwhile kept a low profile; mainly because they both believe they already have the necessary pieces of the puzzle to be successful this coming campaign.
So where does that leave the Florida Panthers in this competition?
Maybe not last in the division, because Tampa Bay and Atlanta may yet struggle with so many new signings, but certainly not first either. The playoffs seem a long long way off this time around for the Cats and their faithful. Whilst I have much faith in head coach DeBoer, I don’t believe him to be a miracle worker either and with the current roster the Panthers would need a team effort to defy the very fabrics of logic to be successful. This may well be out of the hands of both DeBoer and Sexton to provide. Indeed, if we today look at the clubs best potential starting line-up, it could look something like this:
Forwards:
Booth – Weiss – Horton
Stillman – Reinprecht – Frolik
Olesz – Campbell – Dvorak
Tarnasky – Kreps – Repik
Defenders:
Leopold – Ballard
Allen – Koistinen
Garrison/Ellerby – McCabe
(with Kulikov and Wilson as dark horses; possibly making the team)
Goalies:
Vokoun
Clemmensen
Now, there is still plenty of time to make additional signings. Especially the forward compartment seems threadbare and veteran Ville Peltonen would be tipped as one player to return once a decent deal can be thrashed out.
What strikes one when looking at this possible line-up is that it can barely be seen as better than last years. In fact, the defense most definitely seems weakened with the departures of three of last season’s top four defenders: Bouwmeester, Skrastins and Boynton.
Even the forward compartment looks lighter with Zednik departing for Russia, Peltonen not yet signed, and only Reinprecht coming in as a new signing. The goaltending compartment however, still looks like it contains one of the stronger goaltending tandems of the league. Craig Anderson was ably replaced by Scott Clemmensen and it looks like coach DeBoer again will have two quality netminders to toy with.
The one saving grace of this year’s Cats is their investment in young up-and-coming players from within the organization. Players like Repik, Ellerby, Garrison, Matthias and Kulikov are unpolished gems that could very well burst onto the scene and blossom into very exciting prospects this year – as Michael Frolik did last. Furthermore, players such as: Booth, Weiss, Horton, Olesz, Campbell, Koistinen and Wilson – may also have their best seasons ahead of them and could continue to grow in stature this coming season, whilst Bryan Allen hopefully will have recovered from injury to play an important part in the campaign.
But whilst these young and upcoming players provide an injection of energy and hope to the club and its fans, there is also a risk of pegging too much weight of expectation on their shoulders. There is a danger such a strategy could backfire unless there is a strong core of veterans and leaders in the dressing room to balance the bill. McCabe, Stillman, Allen and Vokoun will surely all be looked upon for such roles in the near future. If this is coupled with a hardy dose of patience – there could indeed be a recipe of future success in this mix.
It may however, be too much to ask for, when hoping for immediate success this coming season. Panther fans should be aware; this could very well turn out to be yet another rebuilding season for the Cats. And the franchise owners should also beware; the lack of star signings may deter people from showing up at the Bank Atlantic Center.
The line being trodden is a thin one indeed; startling success or spectacular failure – could equally be found in this upcoming campaign. While it is too early to tell which one it will be, fact is that the early days of July; has ultimately brought more apprehension than hope to hockey fans in South Florida.


